If The Nightmare Upstairs: What Happened to Ty and Bryn? (our verdict: 5.5/10) left you scrolling for something similar, these 8 picks scratch the same itch. Every one has been watched and reviewed by us — no algorithm filler, just what actually comes next.
The Nightmare Upstairs: What Happened to Ty and Bryn? streams on Hulu; the picks below are spread across the usual suspects, and each review says where to watch.
Image courtesy of TMDB. Used under license.
Why it's a match: Same documentary energy.
A college student sued Pepsi over a fighter jet advertised as a joke — and somehow the story only gets wilder from there.
Read the review →
Image courtesy of TMDB. Used under license.
Why it's a match: Same documentary energy.
Harrowing and heartbreaking — the true story of Maya Kowalski stays with you long after it's over.
Read the review →
Image courtesy of TMDB. Used under license.
Why it's a match: Same documentary energy.
A real-time crime doc that feels less like television and more like a heart attack.
Read the review →
Image courtesy of TMDB. Used under license.
Why it's a match: Same documentary energy.
Forget eating clean—this is what happens when you fall for a very dirty con. Bad Vegan proves that sometimes the biggest red flag is believing you can live forever.
Read the review →
Image courtesy of TMDB. Used under license.
Why it's a match: Same documentary energy.
Was Karen Read guilty or framed? Our true-crime review breaks down the snowstorm murder trial that turned a college town into a conspiracy battleground.
Read the review →
Image courtesy of TMDB. Used under license.
Why it's a match: Same documentary energy.
A Glasgow pathologist meets a man on Tinder, gets engaged within weeks, and learns he killed a cyclist and buried the body. Then she stays — and helps police bring him down.
Read the review →
Image courtesy of TMDB. Used under license.
Why it's a match: Same documentary energy.
Six years after Amy Berg re-opened the case, the conclusion finally arrives — and the wait for justice was worth it.
Read the review →
Image courtesy of TMDB. Used under license.
Why it's a match: Same documentary energy.
The most chilling phone calls you'll ever hear, which leaves you guessing, who is the killer?!
Read the review →Start with Pepsi, Where's My Jet? or Take Care of Maya. Both sit in the same corner of The Scream as The Nightmare Upstairs: What Happened to Ty and Bryn?, and we've reviewed every title on this page so you're not going in blind.
We gave it 5.5/10. A small-town disappearance, a quiet suspect, and a documentary that refuses to give you the catharsis you want. Devastating filmmaking.
We list 8 shows like The Nightmare Upstairs: What Happened to Ty and Bryn?: Pepsi, Where's My Jet?, Take Care of Maya, Crime in Progress, Bad Vegan, The Trial of Karen Read, Should I Marry a Murderer?, The Case Against Adnan Syed, 911: Did the Killer Call. Every one has a full Stream & Scream review.
Pepsi, Where's My Jet? is our highest-rated pick here with 9/10, streaming on Netflix. A college student sued Pepsi over a fighter jet advertised as a joke — and somehow the story only gets wilder from there.
The picks on this page are spread across Netflix, Max, while The Nightmare Upstairs: What Happened to Ty and Bryn? itself streams on Hulu. Each review says where to watch.