If The Many Lives of Benjaman Kyle (our verdict: 5/10) left you scrolling for something similar, these 8 picks scratch the same itch. Every one has been watched and reviewed by us — no algorithm filler, just what actually comes next.
The Many Lives of Benjaman Kyle streams on Netflix; the picks below are spread across the usual suspects, and each review says where to watch.
Image courtesy of TMDB. Used under license.
Why it's a match: Hand-picked next binge after The Many Lives of Benjaman Kyle.
A friendly hiker dies on the Florida trail with no ID, no past, and no answers — until the internet decides to solve him.
Read the review →
Image courtesy of TMDB. Used under license.
Why it's a match: Same documentary and cold-case energy.
A son turns the camera on his own family to uncover who killed his mother — and discovers grief, suspicion, and secrets in equal measure.
Read the review →
Image courtesy of TMDB. Used under license.
Why it's a match: Same documentary and true-crime energy.
A haunting, methodical look at a crime that changed the way America bought medicine.
Read the review →
Image courtesy of TMDB. Used under license.
Why it's a match: Same true-crime and documentary energy.
Harrowing and heartbreaking — the true story of Maya Kowalski stays with you long after it's over.
Read the review →
Image courtesy of TMDB. Used under license.
Why it's a match: Same true-crime and documentary energy.
A real-time crime doc that feels less like television and more like a heart attack.
Read the review →
Image courtesy of TMDB. Used under license.
Why it's a match: Same documentary and true-crime energy.
Forget eating clean—this is what happens when you fall for a very dirty con. Bad Vegan proves that sometimes the biggest red flag is believing you can live forever.
Read the review →
Image courtesy of TMDB. Used under license.
Why it's a match: Same documentary and true-crime energy.
Was Karen Read guilty or framed? Our true-crime review breaks down the snowstorm murder trial that turned a college town into a conspiracy battleground.
Read the review →
Image courtesy of TMDB. Used under license.
Why it's a match: Same documentary and true-crime energy.
A Glasgow pathologist meets a man on Tinder, gets engaged within weeks, and learns he killed a cyclist and buried the body. Then she stays — and helps police bring him down.
Read the review →Start with They Called Him Mostly Harmless or Murder on Middle Beach. Both sit in the same corner of The Scream as The Many Lives of Benjaman Kyle, and we've reviewed every title on this page so you're not going in blind.
We gave it 5/10. A man with no memory, a film crew with too much faith, and a story that keeps rewriting itself.
We list 8 shows like The Many Lives of Benjaman Kyle: They Called Him Mostly Harmless, Murder on Middle Beach, The Tylenol Murders, Take Care of Maya, Crime in Progress, Bad Vegan, The Trial of Karen Read, Should I Marry a Murderer?. Every one has a full Stream & Scream review.
Take Care of Maya is our highest-rated pick here with 9/10, streaming on Netflix. Harrowing and heartbreaking — the true story of Maya Kowalski stays with you long after it's over.
The picks on this page are spread across Max, HBO Max, Netflix, while The Many Lives of Benjaman Kyle itself streams on Netflix. Each review says where to watch.